Can Supplementing with Omega 3 Fish Oil Be a Waste of Time or Worse?
There is quite a lot to say about cod liver oil, the traditional mother of all supplementations, especially for older generations. Yet I stopped taking it a number of years ago. Why?
In this article I will recap on some vital knowledge about our Omega intake and convey some recent observations by Paul Mason MD. It would seem that there are powerful implications for inflammatory conditions and their prevention and it is useful to better understand essential Omega oils.
Paul Mason MD is an Aussie doctor who has a presence online; people love him or hate him. To some he makes perfect sense and is eloquent in his transmittal of complex science. To others his challenges to their thinking are inconvenient - but isn’t that what science is all about? One thing is for sure, he does a lot of research and seems to have an eye for a well-designed and interesting study.
What Was, and Is, Cod Liver Oil Taken For?
In the first half of the 20th century, kids at school in the UK were given cod liver oil. Rickets, a Vitamin D deficiency that leads to bone malformation was the principal reason for this policy. Cod liver oil is rich in fat soluble vitamins A and D. It is commendable that UK public policy existed after the Second World War to provide school children with Vitamin D, through cod liver oil; vitamin D is recommended in the UK, but too few people know about it or take it, and deficiency is prevalent, has significant impact on the health of the nation, but could be easy to administer at very low cost.
Latterly, however, fish oil supplementation has been promoted commercially, and become popular, for its anti-inflammatory Omega 3 content.
A Common Pronouncement That Doesn’t Give the Full Picture
Back in 2015 when I wrote my first book, I too was eager to convey a message of the huge imbalance of Omega 3 to Omega 6 consumption that exists in the modern diet. The pro and anti inflammatory potential of Omegas 6 and 3 needs to be fairly equally balanced to remain healthy. Unfortunately due to the explosion in consumption of pro inflammatory Omega 6 in plant oils, combined with other factors, we have seen an overwhelming increase in chronic inflammatory diseases. But, as Paul Mason is keen to point out, restricting Omega 6 intake is not the whole picture and its conversion to Arachidonic acid in the body even at high levels is not always problematic …. It depends on its dietary source and an individual’s existing state of health.
The Problem With Consuming Omega Fatty Acids In Cooking Oils or Supplement Form
Globally we consume a huge amount of liquid fats. It is common now in most restaurants, both fast food and high end, used in most prepared foods and processed junk foods and a go-to purchase at the supermarket, for home cooking in the form of seed oils and even olive oil. Unfortunately the so called healthy Omega 3 and Omega 6 fatty acids in our cooking oils and fish supplements are poly-unsaturated fats that are highly unstable to light and heat.
Oxidised (Damaged) Omega Fatty Acids From Seed Oils and Fish Supplements Cannot Only Create Inflammation in the Body, But Can Exacerbate Existing Inflammation As Well
As we all know by now the on-going battle is to keep levels of inflammation in our body low. An inflammatory response is part of the body’s way of dealing with external attacks, be they viral, bacterial, chemical or other forms of stress. The inflammatory response needs to be short and sharp because otherwise it can become damaging to healthy tissue. In today’s world many of us suffer from on-going inflammation (chronic inflammation) which is the root of our chronic diseases. Therefore, it is important to identify and avoid all potential external triggers that can cause further inflammatory responses in our body.
All the Omega fatty acids are beneficial to us, in the correct ratios, and indeed you will find health shops selling supplements of Omega 3, 6 and 9. Amongst other things, Omega 3 is taken for its anti-inflammatory properties.
If we consume healthy whole foods we would receive adequate amounts of our omegas in optimal ratio. Seed oils, however, allow for greater concentrations of the omega fatty acids, in large and unhealthy ratios, not found in nature and in addition have been oxidised in their production and storage.
Molecularly Unstable, Omega Fats In Seed Oils and Supplements Are Easily Damaged and Can Lead to Toxicity
Confusion has occurred in the assumption that Omega 6, converted to Arachidonic acid in the body then turns into inflammatory products. However, it has been observed that this does not happen when there are no significant inflammatory triggers and the fats are not oxidised during production. Meaning that if our bodies are healthy and not experiencing elevated levels of inflammation, high levels Arachidonic acid (from undamaged poly-unsaturated omega fats) can be beneficial. Studies even show that people on a low carbohydrate diet actually increased beneficial levels of Arachidonic acid, where otherwise they may have been broken down into inflammatory compounds.
Rancid Before We Even Consume It
So to reiterate, our health may be being severely affected, not simply by the ratio of Omega 6 to Omega 3 or by how these oils are processed and stored, but also because our own levels of internal inflammation can trigger an even greater cascade of inflammation. Existing inflammation caused by excess sugar consumption, other environmental factors, stress, high blood sugar levels and the damaged seed oils themselves. The Omega polyunsaturated fats in the seed oils are inherently unstable and oxidise extremely quickly rendering them toxic and severely toxic if we are already in poor health.
Shelled walnuts turn rancid quickly once exposed to heat and light. They will quickly oxidise (go rancid) when subject to heat and light. Seed oils go through heat processing in their manufacture and even the oil from olives, once extracted from the olive (even if cold pressed) is exposed to light and heat when stored over time and especially if cooked with.
The Same Applies to Fish Oil
Fish oil is a big business carried out on an industrial scale so it is hard to retain a process where the fish liver oil remains fresh and unoxidized. My preference is to obtain my Omega 3 through meat and fish. Mackerel, sardines and, in general, like with all things, we should try to obtain our nutrients through whole foods, wherever possible.
A Note For Our Sanity
At this point I would just like to say, as I am half Italian, that when it comes to olive oil, I am not advocating that we should stop consuming it. Buy the best quality you can afford, in small, dark bottles, so once opened they do not sit on the shelf for too long. Avoid cooking with it; saving it for salads perhaps. If you are in the process of reclaiming your health, then maybe it is opportune to avoid it for the time being.
How Do We Know Which Fats Are Safe?
The more solid fat is at room temperature, the more stable it is, and less prone to oxidation. In addition, to consume fat safely, you need to minimise your blood sugar levels, because blood sugar prompts the body to release insulin whose nickname is “the fat storage hormone”. When insulin is circulating in our bloodstream we burn far less fat, and more dietary fat is stored rather than being used for energy. The more fat we store rather than use as energy, the more our cells fill with fat and the more that leads to an inflammatory environment within our body.
In a study where oxidised liquid oils were given to three groups: well controlled diabetics, poorly controlled diabetics and healthy individuals, the level of oxidised products that lead to high levels of internal inflammation were present in significantly greater amounts in the poorly controlled diabetics.
So What is the Moral of the Story?
If we are going to consume fat in the form of liquid oils it is essential that we strictly control our blood sugar levels. In fact if we consume fat in any form it is best to control our blood sugars ….
On a final note saturated fat intake may be protective and restorative with regards to alcohol consumption and in a study cited below polyunsaturated fats can further exacerbate the damage to the liver caused by alcohol. Those “Frenchies” knew a thing or two, ending their meals with full fat cheeses with their wine! More about that in a future article.
Marina Young, Hampshire, England
REFERENCES
Paul Mason interview with Nutrition with Judy: Are the Masai healthy? Is omega 6 really unhealthy?
Dietary carbohydrate restriction improves metabolic syndrome independent of weight loss https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31217353/
Comparison of Low Fat and Low Carbohydrate Diets on Circulating Fatty Acid Composition and Markers of Inflammation
Dietary Fat and Alcoholic Liver Disease – Esteban Mezey
https://aasldpubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/hep.510280401
Metabolism of Arachidonic acid of the skin and its significance in the pathophysiology of inflammatory dermatosis