A few years ago I was privileged to visit one of the northernmost settlements in the Arctic Circle.  One of the local Inuit inhabitants explained to us that “traditionally ALL our food would have been sourced from there” and he pointed to the sea with his hand; he said “and anyway, in the Arctic nothing grows more that 4cm in height”.  I clocked this fact but did not realise until a few weeks later what a massive crack it was on my monument to the benefits of fibre.  There are in fact many other peoples around the world, especially nomadic tribes, that survive essentially on dairy produce and meat. 

On my return to the UK my personal experience with two family members led me to really reassess something that I never thought I would challenge.  Good grief … I even announced at the end of my thank you speech at a birthday party, a few years back:

“… and eat more fibre!!”

My personal experience with two family members changed my mind.  One suffered with diverticulitis and Crohn’s and was told she had no option but to have a colostomy bag fitted and the other ended up with a twisted bowel that culminated in a considerable length of colon being removed.  

As is my way, when big events such as these happen in the life of my family, I want to be as informed as I can be on the subject.  So off I went to research.   Sometimes when you have not been officially “taught” something with “the facts”, but instead are presented with all sorts of different opinions, as is often the case these days, it is arguable that it is easier to be open but also critical and analytical of the information you find.  What I found was that the official advice didn’t seem to make sense or, in reality, provide relief.  Yet the information that challenged the established line not only made sense when faced with a painful and difficult situation but provided relief and improvement.

So what was the new information that made so much sense and successfully challenged my position on fibre:

  • Non-plant food, i.e the fat and protein derived from animals is almost completely absorbed by the small intestine.

  • Fibre and carbohydrates are not considered essential nutrients, and animal foods such as meat, fish, eggs and organ meats are among the most nutrient-dense foods we can eat. Many people who avoid plant food altogether appear to get the nutrition they need for growth, maintenance and repair from a well-chosen animal-based diet.

  • Cutting out plant food greatly reduces what reaches the colon, which may give it a chance to rest and recover.

  • The above points are borne out by people that do, unfortunately, have colostomy bags.  People who have had a colostomy bag for a long time often become savvy and understand that what is medically termed a “low residue diet” i.e a low fibre diet will not lead to overfilled colostomy bags that are at risk of rupturing or need changing frequently.  

  • Many people find that pain, bloating and constipation improve when they reduce fibre, and doctors use low-residue diets for some bowel conditions for this reason. A 2012 study of 63 people with constipation found that those who stopped eating fibre saw their symptoms improve markedly (see references). 

  • Some researchers now question whether fibre protects against diverticular disease. One study, listed below, found a high-fibre diet did not protect against diverticulosis.

  • Some of the foods that contain fibre, such as grains and beans, also contain anti-nutrients, compounds like phytates and lectins that can reduce how well we absorb certain minerals.  How?

    • Firstly fibre is known to speed up the transit time of food through the intestine.  This is not necessarily a good thing as animal foods need to given the time they need to be fully absorbed by the small intestine.  It might seem wasteful to spend the money on an expensive ribeye steak only to push it through your system, with fibrous foods, before the body has fully absorbed its nutrients.

    • The carbohydrates in plant foods such as grains need nutrients such as magnesium and B vitamins to be metabolised. Using precious nutrients to metabolise these foods redirects these nutrients away from body enhancing processes that can increase well-being.

    • Lectins, a topic that has generated a lot of interest in recent times, are the toxins that some plants use as self-defence mechanism against being eaten.  Wheat germ agglutinin, found in wheat, is one example, but an extreme example are the lectins in kidney beans.  These are so toxic that just 5, ill-prepared, kidney beans could make you very ill, though proper soaking and cooking destroys them.

Let me say at this point that I am not advocating that people should give up vegetables.  I am pointing out that sometimes our bodies get into trouble and perhaps this information is useful to know.  It certainly was in the case of my relatives.  Even the established medical community have a term and a use for “low residue diets”.  

On a final point much is written about fibre and the microbiome and the importance of diverse gut flora; the pros and cons of Firmicutes versus Bacteroidetes. Yet some studies have found that meat eaters can have just as diverse a gut flora as plant eaters.  The bacterial colonies do, obviously, differ significantly.  I believe, as always, that we still have so much to learn and we need to keep an open mind.

To conclude this article let me briefly tell you the two anecdotal stories relating to my relatives.  

My first relative, with diverticulitis and Crohn’s had an infection due to a perforated bowel.  She felt poorly but did not have a temperature and did not realise what was going on.  For about a week, whilst staying at my house, she was off her food but did agree to cups of freshly made bone broth with grated cheese a couple of times a day.  Her general malaise did not improve and she decided to go and see a doctor.  This developed into hospitalization where a perforated bowel was eventually diagnosed.  She was told that she would need a colostomy bag.  This was shocking to her but she was told that it would be essential.  She remained in hospital during which time she continued consuming mainly bone and chicken broth and plain yoghurt.  

Due to hospital issues the operation kept getting delayed.  Eventually she decided that if she was to have the surgery she would prefer to return home and have it at a hospital closer to where she lived.  This produced further delays.  In the end and much to everyone’s surprise she seemed to make an excellent recovery on her own.  The colostomy bag was deemed unnecessary and to this day she has not had need for one. This is one person’s experience. Please follow medical advice for a perforated bowel.  She has lowered her fibre intake significantly and, despite her age (86) she is managing her condition much better and enjoying a better quality of life.

My second relative is my dad, who I have written about before.  About a decade ago he suffered from a twisted bowel and had to have surgery to have a large section of his colon removed.  As I have written previously, since this episode, he made a choice to actively avoid fibre and has done so for a number of years.  He is 96 now.  Up to this day he no longer suffers from constipation, in fact, following a recent stay in hospital due to pneumonia, his bowel movements were observed as being “exemplary” by his consultant!  He has survived being bed ridden for 5 weeks with virtually no cognitive or physical decline.  All this despite his fibreless diet ….

Marina Young, Hampshire, England

The Thin Guide to Fat is Marina’s beautifully crafted short book on how weight is gained….and lost, by understanding how fat is actually used and stored in the body. It showcases Marina’s inimitable elevated yet plain-spoken style to reveal the quiet revolution happening in our understanding of metabolic health.

Available for sale in both physical and digital formats. Buy your copy today.

References       

  1. A High-Fiber Diet Does Not Protect Against Asymptomatic Diverticulosis https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3724216/ 

  2. Primary constipation: An underlying mechanism

    Author B.A. Sikirov

    Elsevier Volume 28, Issue 2, February 1989, Pages 71-73

    https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/0306987789900169?via%3Dihub

  3. Diverticular Disease — A Re-examination of the Fiber Hypothesis
    By Tonia Reinhard, MS, RD Today’s Dietitian Vol. 16 No. 3 P. 46 https://www.todaysdietitian.com/newarchives/030314p46.shtml

  4. Stopping or reducing dietary fiber intake reduces constipation and its associated symptoms
    Ho KS et al. World Journal of Gastroenterology, 2012 https://doi.org/10.3748/wjg.v18.i33.4593