Shocked, Cold... and Happy
How cold therapy activates and increases our brown fat. An ignored but extremely potent tool for optimal health, happiness and reversing depression.
Precious Knowledge Lost for a Thousand Years
The last half of the 19th century and the first half of the 20th century was, it can be argued, a golden age in the advancement of knowledge. Many foundational principles of science were laid down during that time. An area, however, that seems to have fallen through the net was further investigation of the ancient concept of Thermalism. Known and named by the ancient Greeks; the Romans also used hot water baths and cold water baths for enhancing health and remedying all sorts of ailments. Yet the concept declined almost into oblivion for over a thousand years.
An Atlantic Tragedy May Have Kept Knowledge Buried for Longer
The sinking of the Titanic may well have been another nail in the coffin of cold water therapy, as the tragedy in the mid Atlantic served to highlight the dangers of hypothermia and death if you were submerged in cold water. In fact it was not really until the 1970s that the whole topic started to be looked at again and from the beginning of the 2000s the pace of research has quickened in this field with some exciting findings.
The Soeberg Institute Has Become a Hub of Knowledge For Cold and Heat Therapies
Dr Susanna Soeberg has taken a deep dive into much of the existing research on the benefits of cold water swimming and cold water plunges together with sauna therapy. In addition she has coordinated further research; her work is on-going and producing exciting results.
Cold Exposure Increases a Sense of Well-Being
It Can Be Beneficial For:
Enhancing Mood
Increasing Resilience
Preventing Stress and Anxiety
Increasing the Resilience of Our Cells
Offers Relief from Chronic Pain (Which is Exacerbated by Stress)
Enables Faster Recovery from Exercise
Increasing Brown Fat Which In Turn Is Responsible For:
Increased Uptake of Stored Energy Leading to Weight Loss
Protecting Against Cardiovascular Disease
Lowering Blood Pressure
Increasing Insulin Sensitivity
Increasing Metabolic Efficiency (and Therefore Energy Levels)
Protecting Against Chronic Diseases
Just like our muscles, brown fat starts to reduce after the age of 40 but cold therapy can help maintain healthy levels.
Heat Exposure Increases a Sense of Well-Being
It Can Be Beneficial For:
Enhancing Mood
Reducing Inflammation
Increasing Metabolic Efficiency Which leads to
Increasing Energy Levels and Fitness
Enables Faster Recovery From Exercise
Offers Relief from Chronic Pain
Protects Against Cardiovascular Disease
Protecting Against Chronic Disease
Lowering the Risk of Infection
Improving Lung Function
These hot and cold therapies when combined with understanding of correct techniques for breathing are proving to be life changing for the people that adopt these habits. Learning to improve the way we breathe can also help to reduce stress, offer better quality of sleep, stop breathlessness and reduce blood pressure.
The idea of exposure to cold water is off-putting to most yet those that persevere are rewarded with these important short term and long term benefits listed above. The threshold of tolerance to cold therapy increases over time so where you may barely manage 5 seconds initially, over a few days or weeks, 30 seconds under a cold water drench becomes manageable and exhilarating.
Dr Susanna Soeberg, interestingly, points out that we have between 3-10 times more cold receptors on our skin than heat receptors; making it far harder for humans to tolerate the cold compared to the heat. Short exposures of seconds to a few minutes appear enough; Søberg suggests around 11 minutes a week in total. Sauna therapy by contrast plateaus at about 20-30 minutes in one session after which benefits can fall away and like with cold water, prolonged exposure can become harmful.
The duration and temperatures may vary amongst individuals but Dr Soeberg’s book “Winter Swimming: The Nordic Way Towards a Healthier and Happier Life” offers recommendations based on the results of her studies and those of others, including a Finnish study that has taken place over 27 years of some 2000 people. These studies show immediate benefits even at minimum exposure but once adapted to the cold, Soeberg recommends that winter cold water swimmers, for example, limit their exposure to 11 minutes in total per week, spread over 3 to 4 days. For sauna’s, the sweet spot was pegged at 57 minutes per week.
With practice, as you would if you were building muscle in the gym and instead of small increments in weights, you slowly build up your time exposure to the cold, you will eventually surpass the cold stress response (breathing techniques will help with this). The 30 second threshold seems to be the sweet spot where the magic happens and apart from the health benefits, it is at this point that mental benefits really kick in.
Both the brain and the adrenals produce Noradrenaline and cold water therapy can increase noradrenaline by around 530% and dopamine by around 250%; this can prevent lethargy, lack of concentration, ADHD and possibly depression, all associated with low levels of this neurotransmitter/hormone (1) Bursts of Noradrenaline can lead to euphoria and enhanced mood. The increase in Dopamine (the happy hormone) that a cold water plunge gives, can last up to 4 hours in the body which allows a feeling of well-being and focus for the rest of the day. This is in contrast to the acute Dopamine hit that is achieved with alcohol or cocaine that leads to a rapid Dopamine crash shortly after.
WHO statistics show that the levels of medication for anxiety and depression are increasing significantly. So for those, and there are too many, who are feeling depressed, apathetic or indifferent this can be a game changer.
Allowing ourselves to feel colder adapts our body to cold as brown fat is stimulated. A 2014 study measured brown fat in the body using PET/CT scans. Individuals were first asked to sleep every night for a month in a warm room and then the following month in a room at 19C. After the second month their brown fat measurements had increased and so had their sensitivity to insulin.
Unlike white fat, increased levels of brown fat are healthy. It is activated immediately by temperature variation and is the temperature regulator in our body enabling our metabolism to function optimally. There are more Mitochondria (our energy cells) in brown fat, compared to white fat that increase the uptake and activation of stored energy, leading to greater fuel efficiency and enhanced energy levels. People with less brown fat are more susceptible to type 2 diabetes and weight gain.
Dr Susanna Soeberg rightly points out that unfortunately brown fat is perceived as “mystical”, it is “under rated and hardly ever mentioned”.
The interest in the ancient adoption of Thermalism together with renewed attention on brown fat has come about with new technology that allows us to see so much more the workings of our body and therefore understand it in a way that we did not have access to before. The parameters of benefit to undesirable effects on the body may be narrow and vary between individuals. As with all advice we must take it on board with an acceptance of personal attention and responsibility for as time progresses theories and opinions change. Do what feels right for you and (if you are a man) do not enter this process with a competitive frame of mind! Cold plunges can be dangerous if you have heart problems, so check with your doctor first.
In the notes below are references to Dr Soeberg’s book, published paper and website. Take a look and find out how to incorporate this life enhancing therapy effectively and safely into your life.
Marina Young, Hampshire, England
Polls
References
PubMed: Altered brown fat thermoregulation and enhanced cold-induced thermogenesis in young, healthy, winter-swimming men https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34755128/
Book: “Winter Swimming: “The Nordic Way Towards a Healthier and Happier Life”
Endocrine Society