Vanity, Dodgy Data and Statins
Statins promise much but statistically deliver next to nothing and are being pushed far and wide, with possible harmful side effects including depression. Why?
As some of you may know, the main thrust of my weekly articles is unpicking and summarising some of the work done by the doctors and scientists that are challenging some fundamentals in the world of health and medicine. Making more people aware of their work by extracting the essential points out of books, lectures and research. This enables more people to become familiar with some of the challenges and questions around health and nutrition that could affect us, our family and our friends.
As I have been thinking about the growing number of individuals who are seriously and eloquently questioning the allopathic approach to health (the focusing on treating the symptoms of disease, rather than dealing with underlying cause), especially when it comes to chronic, inflammatory and autoimmune diseases, it struck me that many of these contributors have some characteristics in common. A lovely demeanour, passion and an absence of vanity; at least that I can perceive. Names that spring to mind, in no particular order are:
Dr Dale Bredesen (expert neurodegenerative disease),
Dr Richard Johnson (practicing physician and clinical scientist),
Dr Tim Noakes (Emeritus Professor in the Division of Exercise Science and Sports Medicine at the University of Cape Town ,
Dominic D’Agostino PhD (tenured associate Professor Dept of Molecular Pharmacology and Physiology University of South Florida),
Dr James Di Nicolantonio (cardiovascular research scientist and Dr of Pharmacy),
Dr Natasha Campbell McBride (MMedSci Neurology/ MMedSci Nutrition).
Dr Ali Nadir (cardiologist),
Dr Paul Mason (practicing physician),
Dr Michael Eades (practicing physician),
Dr Malcolm Kendrick (practicing physician),
Dr Jason Fung (Nephrologist),
Ivor Cummins (Chemical Engineer),
Amber O’Hearn (data researcher),
Dave Feldman (software engineer),
These names are but a few of the individuals that, I repeat, I perceive to be willing to be intellectually challenged and pursue their work with passion and humility.
Don’t Challenge Me, You Don’t Understand Anything
Vanity, I believe, is a very real hindrance to good science and nowhere has it been more overtly on display than when Dr Anthony Fauci, ex head of NIAID (part of the National Institutes of Health in America), suggested that attacks on him were attacks on science!
Shaking Off Old Ideas is as Slow as Continental Drift
Most of the doctors and scientists listed above have had to hang their professional reputations on the line when questioning the established narrative of many topics. Unfortunately, this has always been the case in science, the institutions seem to reject new thinking in favour of the old established ideas; the longer ‘the science’ has been established the harder it is to oust it, no matter how much evidence builds against it. We all know the famous case of Galileo challenging the Catholic Church’s dogma that the Earth was the centre of the universe but a more recent one from the 20th century, that may raise an eyebrow or two, is the example of the tectonic plate theory. More than 100 years ago the concept of continental drift was considered pseudoscience (1). The German meteorologist, Alfred Wegener, was ridiculed for advancing the shocking idea that the continents were adrift. For the duration of his lifetime geological thinking stood firmly by the old dogma that the continents and oceans were permanent features that never shifted and changed.
As Richard Conniff wrote in a Smithsonian Magazine article:
“We like to imagine that knowledge advances fact upon dispassionate fact to reveal precise and irrefutable truths. But there is hardly a better example of just how messy and emotional science can be than Wegener’s discovery of the vast, turbulent forces moving within the earth’s crust. As often happens when confronted with difficult new ideas, the establishment joined ranks and tore holes in his theories, mocked his evidence and maligned his character.”
Wegener published his final theory of continental drift in 1929 but it was not until the old guard died off within the institutions plus the advent of new technology that his theories were proved correct and accepted in the mid 1960s
Shameful Use of Data and Statistics
Today we witness independent thinkers thrash out the why and how of their theories and opinions, opening themselves up to criticism but rarely being allowed to address their critics face to face. I believe that ordinary, self-educated people should be more easily able to witness the why and how of both sides of the argument, instead the pharmaceutical/allopathic side has developed a reputation for obfuscation, lack of transparency and some very dodgy use of statistics in their clinical studies. Extremely serious challenges have been made to some of these studies that invariably are left unaddressed. Again, no better example of this are the published statistics on the supposed benefits of statins; the use of numbers for relative risk over absolute risk. This topic is spelled out in detail by Dr Malcolm Kendrick in his books “Doctoring the Data” and “The Cholesterol Myth”.
Chastised By the British Medical Journal
The promotion of statins sits on some very questionable evidence. In fact, in 2017 when a major, long term study was published, backing statins for patients with high LDL and no other risk factors (2), a Rapid Response letter published on the BMJ website “chastised researchers who committed “sins” against transparent reporting, such as presenting relative risk (which inflates the appearance of interventions) without presenting absolute risk (which provides a more appropriate assessment of the benefit of an intervention).”
From Statistically Insignificant to Utterly Amazing! Really?
When you see this in actual numerical terms as fed to the general public, you see the level of distortion of the real outcomes. The study was used to claim that statins “reduced deaths from coronary heart disease by 28% in men with very high levels of LDL cholesterol over a 20 year follow up period”. 28% reduction in an outcome of death would be an extraordinarily successful number to achieve but the BMJ called it “incomplete and misleading risk information”. The BMJ article went on to say “… the clinically relevant difference in the rate of coronary death between treated and untreated groups was only 2.3%, not 28%”.
Corporate Money Has Corrupted Research and Education
In the May/June 2010 issue of the Boston Review, Dr Marcia Angell, former editor-in-chief of the New England Journal of Medicine, detailed the sordid story of how corporate dollars have corrupted research and education at academic medical centres — including the Harvard Medical School.(3)
Dr Angell wrote:
The boundaries between academic medicine – medical schools, teaching hospitals and their faculty – and the pharmaceutical industry have been dissolving since the 1980s, and the important differences between their missions are becoming blurred. Medical research, education and clinical practice have suffered as a result.
Taking Responsibility Means Being Able to Ask Better Questions
Fortunately for us all today, compared to just a few years ago, we have access to a lot more information. We may not have enough personal knowledge to understand who is right and who is wrong but nonetheless if we take personal responsibility for our health, we can find out whether there are two sides to any given argument and perhaps find a reasonable second opinion on a given situation. This will allow us to ask better questions of the doctors who are treating or advising us. Their attitude to our questioning will also tell a lot.
If your doctor had this sitting on his desk, what would you think?

Marina Young, Hampshire, England
References
Original article has been removed. Excerpts are described in this article: https://www.minnpost.com/second-opinion/2010/05/ex-editor-nejm-tells-how-big-pharma-has-corrupted-academic-institutions/